| Platinum | Twisted Taino Restaurant |
| Gold | Romeo's Pizza |
| Silver | Eddie's Pizzeria Cerino |
| Bronze | Tony's Family Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Au Jus |
| Top Pick | East Coast Original Frozen Custard |
| Top Pick | Fast Eddies |
| Top Pick | Pappous |
| Top Pick | Schnitz Ale Brewery |
| Top Pick | The Club House |