| Platinum | Southside Diner |
| Gold | Victoria's |
| Silver | Tony's Family Restaurant |
| Bronze | John & Loreta Family Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Bakers Square |
| Top Pick | Bob Evans |
| Top Pick | Einstein Bros. Bagels |
| Top Pick | Goody's Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Luna's Deli Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Sips and Such Social House |