| Platinum | Napoleon's Pizza |
| Gold | Rocky's Pizza |
| Silver | Danny Boys |
| Bronze | Corleone's Ristorante & Bar |
| Top Pick | Bucci's J Bella |
| Top Pick | Carrabba's Italian Grill |
| Top Pick | Eddie's Pizzeria Cerino |
| Top Pick | Piada Italian Street Food |
| Top Pick | Stancato's Italian Restaurant |
| Top Pick | The Brick Oven |