| Platinum | Cozumel Mexican Restaurant |
| Gold | Barrio |
| Silver | Blue Habanero |
| Bronze | Chipotle Mexican Grill |
| Top Pick | Don Ramon Mexican Restaurant |
| Top Pick | El Torito Tacos Middleburg Heights |
| Top Pick | Gran Fiesta Mexican Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Momocho |
| Top Pick | Si Senor Restaurant - Kamm's Corners |