| Platinum | Napoleon's Pizza |
| Gold | Romeo's Pizza |
| Silver | Antonios Pizza |
| Bronze | Fratello's Pizza |
| Top Pick | Danny Boys |
| Top Pick | Gentile's Bakery - Catering - Deli |
| Top Pick | Guys Pizza Co. - Parma |
| Top Pick | Marsella's Pizza |
| Top Pick | P.Jay's Pizza |
| Top Pick | Santo's Italian Restaurant |